Probiotics: what they are, what they are studied for and what you should know before taking them
Probiotic has become one of those words we find practically everywhere.
In yoghurts. In capsules. In sachets. In drinks. In advertising. In recommendations on social media.
And perhaps for that very reason it’s used too lightly.
It’s common to hear phrases such as:
“Probiotics are good for your gut.”
“Take probiotics after antibiotics.”
“The more strains, the better.”
“This one has 50 billion, so it must be stronger.”
“You need to take probiotics to restore your microbiota.”
The problem is that none of these statements, put so generally, really explains how probiotics work.
Because not all live microorganisms are probiotics, not all probiotics are the same, and a product with more microorganisms or more strains is not necessarily better.
So the right question isn’t simply:
Do probiotics work?
A much more useful scientific question would be:
Which specific microorganism, in what amount, for what purpose and with what evidence?
Understanding this difference completely changes the way we assess a probiotic product.
The short answer: what is a probiotic?
The reference scientific definition describes probiotics as live microorganisms which, when administered in adequate amounts, confer a health benefit on the host.
The definition seems simple, but it contains three fundamental requirements:
- they must be live microorganisms;
- they must be given in an adequate amount;
- there must be evidence of a health benefit.
So it isn’t enough for a food or supplement to contain live bacteria for us to assume scientifically that those bacteria are probiotic.
ISAPP (the International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics) stresses precisely this point: a true probiotic must contain specific microorganisms, given at a defined dose and studied to show a specific benefit.
This precision matters because it forces us to leave behind an overly simple idea:
“live microorganism = probiotic”.
Not necessarily.
Not all beneficial bacteria are probiotics
Our gut contains a huge community of microorganisms.
Many take part in important functions and normally live alongside us.
But that doesn’t automatically make all those bacteria “probiotics”.
To use the term correctly from a scientific point of view, we need to identify the microorganism and have studies supporting its use.
The same goes for fermented foods.
Yoghurt, kefir, kimchi, sauerkraut, kombucha and other foods may contain live microorganisms.
But fermented and probiotic are not synonyms either.

Fermented foods and probiotics are not synonyms.
In many fermented foods we don’t know precisely which live microorganisms finally reach the consumer, in what amount, or whether those specific strains have shown a particular benefit.
That’s why some fermented foods may contain live microorganisms and be a perfectly good part of a healthy diet without us automatically calling them probiotic foods.
The difference may seem technical.
But it’s fundamental.
Because it lets us separate a characteristic of the food (“it contains live microorganisms”) from a much more demanding conclusion:
“This specific microorganism, in this amount, has shown this particular effect.”
Genus, species and strain: the surname matters
When we buy a probiotic we may come across names that seem written just to make our lives difficult:
Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG.
Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis BB-12.
Saccharomyces boulardii.
But this identification is much more important than it seems.
We can understand it with a simple comparison.
Imagine:
García → family
María García → person
Saying just “Lactobacillus” would be like saying we’re talking about someone from the García family.
We still don’t know exactly who.
In microbiology we usually need to distinguish:
genus → species → strain.
For example:
Lacticaseibacillus → genus
rhamnosus → species
GG → strain
The strain would be the most specific identification.
And this matters because microorganisms belonging to the same species can have different characteristics.
Evidence obtained with one specific strain shouldn’t automatically be applied to any other strain of the same species.
The NIH also recommends identifying probiotic microorganisms by genus, species and strain.
That’s why a label that only says:
“Lactobacillus + Bifidobacterium”
gives us much less information than one that clearly identifies the microorganisms used.

Genus, species and strain: the surname matters because not all probiotics are the same.
So is each strain only good for one thing?
We shouldn’t go to the opposite extreme either.
There are mechanisms that different microorganisms can share.
Some can interact with the gut environment, produce certain metabolites, compete with other microorganisms or communicate in different ways with the host’s cells.
But when we want to link a product with a specific benefit, identifying the microorganism and the available evidence become fundamental again.
The World Gastroenterology Organisation recommends interpreting the evidence on probiotics by taking into account the strain, dose and clinical situation studied, rather than making generic recommendations for the whole category.
This is probably the central idea of this whole article:
The word “probiotic” describes a category. It doesn’t guarantee that all products in that category have the same effects.
How do probiotics work?
Another common idea is to imagine that we take a probiotic to permanently “repopulate” our gut.
The reality is usually more interesting.
Many probiotics don’t need to settle permanently in our microbiota to have their effects.
They can pass through the gastrointestinal tract, interact temporarily with resident microorganisms and with our body, and then disappear.
ISAPP notes that many probiotics don’t remain in the gut for long periods.
Depending on the microorganism studied, mechanisms being investigated include:
- interaction with resident microorganisms;
- competition for certain resources or spaces;
- production of metabolites;
- changes to the gut environment;
- interaction with the gut barrier;
- communication with immune cells;
- influence on various digestive processes.
Not all probiotics act through all of these mechanisms.
And observing a mechanism in the laboratory doesn’t automatically mean a relevant benefit has been shown in people.
This brings up another essential distinction:
a plausible mechanism is not the same as proven clinical effectiveness.
We can show that a bacterium produces a certain substance in a laboratory dish and still need human trials to know whether consuming it has a significant effect.
What are probiotics being studied for?
Research on probiotics is extensive and covers many fields.
Different strains and formulations have been studied in relation to:
- antibiotic-associated diarrhoea;
- certain infectious diarrhoeas;
- constipation;
- irritable bowel syndrome;
- some bowel diseases;
- immune health;
- certain paediatric situations;
- oral health;
- vaginal health;
- metabolism;
- and, increasingly, communication between the microbiota, the gut and the brain.
But this list comes with a huge warning:
the fact that probiotics are being studied for a particular situation doesn’t mean any probiotic is useful for that situation.
Nor does it mean the evidence is equally solid in all these fields.
The NCCIH notes that there are areas in which some formulations have shown promising results, but it also acknowledges that for many applications we still don’t know with enough certainty which probiotics are useful, what dose should be used or which people are most likely to benefit.
Let’s look at some examples to understand why the nuance matters.
Probiotics and antibiotics
This is probably one of the best-known associations.
Antibiotics can change the gut microbiota, and some people develop diarrhoea during or after treatment.
Different probiotic strains have been studied to try to reduce the risk of antibiotic-associated diarrhoea.
There are reviews and guidelines that find certain formulations useful in specific contexts.
But it would be wrong to turn this into:
“After taking antibiotics you need to take any probiotic.”
The evidence depends on the microorganism used, the dose, the timing, the population studied and the type of outcome analysed.
Moreover, a probiotic supplement does not replace or change the prescribed antibiotic regimen.
If there is a medical situation, especially in young children, frail older people, immunocompromised patients or people with serious illnesses, the recommendation needs to be individualised.
Probiotics and bowel transit
Certain strains have also been studied in relation to bowel movement frequency, stool consistency and constipation.
Some studies have found favourable results with certain microorganisms.
Others show more modest or inconsistent results.
Once again, we shouldn’t turn:
“this strain was studied in this context”
into:
“probiotics cure constipation”.
They are completely different statements.
In addition, constipation can have many causes.
Diet, hydration, physical activity, medication, pelvic floor problems and certain diseases can all play a part.
Automatically taking a probiotic without understanding the problem may lead us to ignore much more important factors.
Probiotics and irritable bowel syndrome
This field shows perfectly why talking about “probiotics” in general is problematic.
Many trials have been carried out using very different microorganisms and combinations.
The conclusions are not the same across guidelines, studies and products.
This makes it difficult to make a universal recommendation for the whole category.
When the results depend on the specific strain or combination used, grouping all probiotics together as if they were the same treatment can hide important differences.
It’s a good example of how many studies don’t necessarily mean a simple answer.
The microbiota, the immune system and other fields of research
Gut microorganisms constantly interact with the immune system.
That’s why there is a great deal of research on certain probiotics and various immune parameters.
Possible links with metabolism, mental health and other body systems are also being studied.
These are scientifically interesting fields.
But precisely because they generate so much expectation, they require even more caution.
We can’t jump straight from:
“there is communication between the microbiota and the immune system”
to:
“this probiotic boosts your defences”.
Or from:
“there is a gut-brain axis”
to:
“this probiotic treats anxiety or depression”.
Between one statement and the other, specific evidence is needed, and we must also respect the law on health claims.
This will be especially important when we talk in depth about psychobiotics and the gut-brain axis.
An important point if you are in Spain
There is a difference between the scientific definition of a probiotic and how it is treated by regulators.
AESAN updated its information on probiotics on 20 July 2026 and points out that there is currently no specific legal definition of “probiotic” in European Union food law.
In Spain, use of the term “probiotic(s)” may be accepted on certain foods and supplements, but this does not mean it can be freely accompanied by any health benefit.
AESAN states that the term cannot be accompanied by health claims unless these are authorised under European regulations.
This explains something that is sometimes confusing.
A product may contain microorganisms that we call probiotics scientifically or commercially, and yet the company cannot freely claim in its advertising:
“improves your immunity”
“eliminates inflammation”
“treats your irritable bowel”
“reduces your anxiety”
without meeting the relevant legal conditions.
In addition, food supplements cannot be presented as products intended to prevent, treat or cure diseases.
For consumers, this caution has an advantage:
it forces us to look beyond the marketing phrases.
What are CFU?
When we look at a probiotic supplement we often see figures such as:
1 billion CFU
10 billion
50 billion
CFU stands for colony-forming units and is a common way of expressing the amount of viable microorganisms present.
The figure matters.
But it shouldn’t be seen as a competition.
A product with 50 billion CFU is not automatically five times better than one with 10 billion.
ISAPP explains it clearly: a higher dose doesn’t necessarily mean greater effectiveness, just as adding more strains doesn’t guarantee a superior product.
The right question again is:
Does the amount given match the amount used to show the benefit we’re looking for?
If a particular strain has shown an effect at a specific dose, that information is much more useful than simply looking for the biggest number on the shelf.
Do more strains mean better?
No.
Or at least we can’t say so in general.
A product with fifteen strains can be excellent.
So can one with a single strain.
It all depends on the purpose and the available evidence.
Imagine two products:
Product A
20 strains.
100 billion CFU.
It doesn’t clearly identify some strains.
We don’t know which studies support the combination.
Product B
One fully identified strain.
A specific dose.
Studies carried out with that strain and that amount for the intended purpose.
Which looks more impressive in advertising?
Probably A.
Which can we assess better scientifically?
Probably B.
This doesn’t mean multi-strain formulations are bad.
It means something much simpler:
the number of strains and the quality of evidence are different variables.
A longer list is no substitute for better documentation.
How to read a probiotic label
When assessing a probiotic supplement, it’s worth looking for several pieces of information.
1. Identification of the microorganisms
Ideally we should be able to find:
genus + species + strain.
The more specific the identification, the easier it is to look up whether there is research on that particular microorganism.
2. Amount
We need to know the dose of viable microorganisms provided by the recommended daily amount.
And here there’s another important detail.
The microorganisms are alive.
So some may lose viability during storage.
The NIH recommends, where the information is available, looking for products that guarantee the CFU count until the end of shelf life, not just the amount present at the time of manufacture.
It’s not the same to say:
“contains 20 billion when we make it”
as:
“guarantees 20 billion until the expiry date”.
3. Storage conditions
Some microorganisms need refrigeration.
Others can remain stable at room temperature thanks to the strain used, the manufacturing technology, packaging and product characteristics.
So:
“doesn’t need refrigerating” doesn’t automatically mean it’s worse either.
Follow the storage instructions provided by the manufacturer.
Heat, humidity and unsuitable conditions can affect certain products.
4. Best-before or expiry date
If the viability of the microorganism matters, so does how long it is guaranteed for.
We shouldn’t buy a probiotic while completely ignoring this information.
5. Recommended daily dose
We shouldn’t assume that taking double gives double the benefit.
Food supplements should be used at the dose stated on the label, and AESAN points out that the recommended daily amount should not be exceeded.
6. What evidence exists
This is probably the most important point and the least visible on the label.
Ask yourself:
Is there research on these strains?
Has this combination been studied?
At what dose?
In which population?
For what purpose?
Did the study really assess what the product is implying?
It’s a lot more work than comparing two CFU numbers.
But it’s also a much better way to choose.
Should probiotics be taken on an empty stomach?
There is no universal answer that applies to every product.
The survival of microorganisms may depend on the strain, the formulation and the matrix in which they are given.
That’s why the safest practical recommendation is:
follow the product’s specific instructions.
We shouldn’t arbitrarily change a regimen because we’ve read that “all probiotics should be taken on an empty stomach” or “always at night”.
This topic deserves a separate article because there are differences between formulations and studies.
How long should they be taken for?
There’s no universal duration either.
It depends on:
- the microorganism;
- the purpose;
- the dose;
- the product;
- the population;
- the available evidence.
The NIH notes that there are no general official recommendations for probiotic use in healthy people and advises consulting a professional to decide on the product, dose and duration when needed.
This dismantles another common commercial idea:
“Everyone should take probiotics permanently.”
There’s no basis for a universal recommendation of this kind.
Are probiotics safe?
For most healthy people, commonly used probiotics have a good safety record, and side effects are usually mild, such as wind or some temporary gastrointestinal discomfort.
But “natural” or “beneficial microorganism” doesn’t mean zero risk.
Rare complications, including infections, have been described, mainly in people with significant risk factors.
The NCCIH and NIH point out that special caution is needed in seriously ill people, those with compromised immune systems and certain vulnerable groups. Serious risks have also been documented in premature babies.
That’s why it’s a good idea to consult a healthcare professional before using probiotics in situations such as:
- significant immunosuppression;
- serious illness;
- hospitalisation;
- prematurity;
- certain significant bowel conditions;
- complex medical treatments;
- or doubts about possible personal risks.
A probiotic is a health-related product.
It makes no sense to treat it with less judgement than any other supplement.
Probiotic, prebiotic and synbiotic: not the same thing
They’re easy to confuse.
Probiotic
A live microorganism which, when given in an adequate amount, has been shown to provide a benefit.
Prebiotic
A substrate selectively used by host microorganisms that provides a health benefit.
Synbiotic
A combination of live microorganisms and certain substrates intended to be used by host microorganisms.
So:
probiotic = microorganism
prebiotic = substrate
We shouldn’t confuse “giving bacteria” with “providing food for certain microorganisms”.
Nor should we assume that putting a probiotic and a fibre together automatically creates a superior formulation.
The combination also has to make sense.
Five questions before choosing a probiotic
If, after reading all this, you want to assess a product, you can perhaps forget much of the marketing and ask five questions.
1. Exactly which microorganisms does it contain?
Look for genus, species and, whenever possible, strain.
2. What amount does it provide?
And don’t automatically read a bigger figure as better.
3. Is there evidence on those strains and that dose?
A formulation should be justifiable beyond a nice list of ingredients.
4. What do I want to use it for?
“Looking after your gut” is too broad an expression.
The more specific the purpose, the better we can assess the evidence.
5. Is there any reason I should consult a professional first?
Especially if there are persistent symptoms, illness, medical treatments or risk factors.
These five questions probably give more information than focusing only on the word:
PROBIOTIC
written in large letters on the pack.
The most important thing: the best probiotic isn’t necessarily the one with the most of everything
The supplement industry has an understandable tendency to compete using numbers.
More strains.
More CFU.
More ingredients.
More technology.
More words on the label.
But scientifically “more” doesn’t always mean “better”.
A good probiotic should be able to answer much more important questions:
Which microorganisms does it contain?
Are they correctly identified?
What amount does it provide?
Is that amount maintained throughout its shelf life?
What have those strains been studied for?
Is there relevant evidence?
How should it be stored?
Who is it suitable for, and who should seek advice before taking it?
Once we have those answers, we can start to assess the product.
Before that, we mainly have marketing.
And that’s precisely why talking about probiotics properly means leaving general promises behind and getting into the details.
Because with probiotics, the detail isn’t an extra.
The detail is exactly where the science begins.

What to check before choosing a probiotic: keys to an informed choice
In summary
If we had to keep seven ideas, they would be these:
- Not every live microorganism is automatically a probiotic.
- A true probiotic must contain live microorganisms, be given in an adequate amount and be backed by evidence of a benefit.
- Genus, species and strain matter. Results seen with one specific strain shouldn’t be automatically extrapolated to all of them.
- More CFU doesn’t necessarily mean greater effectiveness.
- More strains don’t automatically mean a better product either.
- Probiotics are being researched in many fields, especially digestive health, but the evidence depends on the microorganism, dose, population and purpose.
- To choose well, it’s better to look less at the advertising and much more at strain identification, dose, stability, storage and the available evidence.
The question shouldn’t be:
“Which is the strongest probiotic?”
Perhaps we should start with another one:
“Which probiotic is right for the purpose I have in mind, and what evidence is there to back it up?”
That question is much less spectacular.
But it lets us make much better decisions.

Recent Comments